Skip To Content

Hilton Head’s Top-Rated Pies and Pizza Spots

I’ve discovered the yummiest spots on Hilton Head for those into scrumptious pizza and delightful pies.

Giuseppi’s Pizza & Pasta fills the air with the aroma of freshly baked dough and offers authentic Italian flavors. The Upper Crust is a hidden gem where pizza feels like art. Dough Boys Pizza’s crust is perfection—crispy outside, soft inside. For dessert lovers, Hilton Head Social Bakery crafts pies and pastries that are a slice of heaven.

Stick around to learn about more spots that’ll satisfy all your cravings.


Picture from:
Facebook

Giuseppi’s Pizza & Pasta

When I first walked into Giuseppi’s Pizza & Pasta, the warm, inviting aroma of freshly baked dough and their special cheese blend instantly made me feel at home. The family-friendly atmosphere buzzed with laughter and conversation, making it clear why this place has been a local favorite for 33 years. I felt like I’d stepped into an Italian haven right here on Hilton Head Island.

One bite of their pizza took me on a journey through authentic Italian flavors. Their fresh dough is made daily, and it shows in every chewy, crisp bite. Pair that with their special cheese blend, and it’s no wonder families keep coming back. I remember chatting with a regular who couldn’t stop raving about their local favorite dishes, like the margherita pizza and the savory meatball sub.

It’s not just the food that makes Giuseppi’s special; it’s the sense of community. The staff treats everyone like family, and you can see the pride in their eyes as they serve up dishes they’ve perfected over decades. If you’re looking to serve others a slice of true Italian delight, Giuseppi’s is the place to be.

The Upper Crust

As I made my way from the cozy embrace of Giuseppi’s, I found myself drawn to The Upper Crust, a hidden gem that promised a completely different yet equally delightful pizza experience. Stepping inside, I felt an immediate sense of warmth and community. The aroma alone of crispy perfection and savory toppings was enough to make my mouth water.

The Upper Crust specializes in artisanal creations that elevate the humble pizza to an art form. Their thin crust is the perfect canvas for a variety of flavorful combinations, each bite a testament to culinary craftsmanship. I remember the first time I bit into their Margherita pizza; the harmony of fresh basil, mozzarella, and tomato was nothing short of divine.

Here are three standout offerings that I believe everyone should try:

  1. Classic Pepperoni: A timeless favorite, reimagined with gourmet pepperoni and a hint of truffle oil.
  2. Farmhouse Special: A hearty mix of fresh vegetables and farm-to-table meats.
  3. Mediterranean Delight: A symphony of olives, feta, and sun-dried tomatoes.

If you’re passionate about serving others and sharing incredible food experiences, The Upper Crust is a must-visit on Hilton Head Island.


Photo credit:
Official Website

Dough Boys Pizza

Why does Dough Boys Pizza instantly feel like home the moment you step inside? For me, it’s the warm, inviting aroma that hits you as soon as you walk through the door. It’s the friendly staff who greet you like an old friend. And then, of course, there’s the pizza.

I remember my first bite of Dough Boys’ signature flavors. The combination of their best crust at Dough Boys—crispy on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside—and their secret sauce was a revelation. It’s like they’ve bottled up comfort and joy and spread it across a perfectly baked crust.

The unique toppings at Dough Boys are another reason I keep coming back. From spicy sausage to artichoke hearts, every bite is an adventure. They even offer seasonal specials that highlight the freshest ingredients, ensuring there’s always something new to try.

It’s not just about the food, though. It’s about the experience. Dough Boys Pizza embodies a sense of community and care, making each visit feel special. So, if you’re looking for a place that serves up more than just a meal, Dough Boys is the place to be.


Photo credit:
Official Website

Mellow Mushroom

Stepping into Mellow Mushroom feels like entering a whimsical world where pizza isn’t just food—it’s an experience. From the moment I walked in, I was captivated by the vibrant, eclectic decor and the friendly atmosphere that invites you to sit back and relax. Mellow Mushroom’s artisan pizzas are simply out of this world, bursting with flavors that make every bite memorable.

One of my highlights was trying their Mushroom Madness specialty pie. The blend of fresh mushrooms and creative toppings like caramelized onions and truffle oil was a delightful surprise. It’s not just about pizza here; it’s about the journey each unique pie takes you on.

Here are my top three reasons why Mellow Mushroom stands out:

  1. Creative Toppings: You’ll find combinations that you won’t encounter anywhere else, making every visit a new adventure.
  2. Casual Dining: The laid-back vibe makes it a perfect spot to unwind, whether you’re with family, friends, or even solo.
  3. Specialty Pies: Their menu offers a range of specialty pies, ensuring there’s something to satisfy every palate.

Source:
Facebook

Hilton Head Social Bakery

Walking into Hilton Head Social Bakery feels like uncovering a hidden gem, where each pastry and pie tells a story of passion and craftsmanship. I remember the first time I stepped inside; the aroma of fresh-baked goods instantly enveloped me, and I was greeted by warm smiles. This isn’t just a place to buy a pie; it’s a sanctuary for dessert enthusiasts.

Their custom cakes are true works of art, crafted with love and meticulous attention to detail. You can taste the difference that local ingredients make in every bite. The bakery isn’t just about selling sweets; it’s about building community. They regularly host community events, turning simple gatherings into memorable experiences. I once attended a pie-tasting event, and the joy in the room was palpable.

The dessert options are endless – from velvety cheesecakes to rich chocolate tarts. If you’re enthusiastic to learn, their baking classes offer hands-on experience, teaching the secrets behind their delectable creations. There’s something incredibly fulfilling about being part of a place that not only serves delicious desserts but also fosters a sense of togetherness. Hilton Head Social Bakery truly captures the essence of community through its sweet offerings.


Image from:
Official Instagram

Local Pie

After indulging in the heavenly desserts at Hilton Head Social Bakery, I couldn’t resist exploring another local gem: Local Pie, where every slice feels like a hug from home. Stepping into Local Pie, I was immediately enveloped by the comforting aroma of freshly baked pies. The warmth of the place and the cheerful staff made me feel like part of a big, happy family.

Their selection of unique pies is astounding. I couldn’t help but marvel at their seasonal pies, each crafted with the freshest ingredients. My favorite moment was the pie tasting event—an unforgettable experience where I savored slices that tasted like autumn and summer colliding in perfect harmony.

Here’s what makes Local Pie stand out:

  1. Pie pairings: They offer delightful recommendations to pair your pie with a perfect beverage, enhancing the flavors.
  2. Pie making classes: Learning to bake pie from their expert bakers was both educational and heartwarming.
  3. Unique pies: From savory to sweet, their creative pies are a culinary adventure.

Every visit to Local Pie feels like a warm embrace, and for anyone who loves to serve others with delicious food, this spot is an absolute must-visit.


Picture from:
Official Website

Salty Dog Pizza

With an air of coastal charm and a reputation for mouthwatering pizza, Salty Dog Pizza quickly became my go-to spot for a delectable slice by the sea. The first time I walked in, I was captivated by the welcoming atmosphere and the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked pizza.

What sets Salty Dog Pizza apart is their perfect blend of savory toppings and a delightfully crispy crust. Each bite is a harmonious mix of textures and tastes, creating flavorful combinations that linger in your memory long after you’ve left. My personal favorite is their seafood twist on a classic pizza, topped with succulent shrimp and a medley of fresh herbs. It’s no wonder this place is a local favorite.

I remember one evening, sharing a seafood pizza with friends as the sun set over the marina. The laughter, the camaraderie, and that amazing pizza created a moment I’ll cherish forever. At Salty Dog Pizza, you’re not just enjoying a meal; you’re experiencing a piece of Hilton Head’s coastal magic. If you’re ever in town, don’t miss out on this extraordinary slice of paradise.


Image from:
Facebook

Frankie Bones

Just when I thought my culinary adventure on Hilton Head couldn’t get any better, I stumbled upon Frankie Bones, a retro-themed restaurant that feels like stepping back into the swanky era of the Rat Pack. The ambiance alone drew me in, but it was the food that truly stole my heart.

One Sunday brunch, I found myself savoring their Eggs Benedict, perfectly balanced with a mimosa in hand. It wasn’t just food; it was an experience. The servers, always attentive and warm, made me feel like part of the Frankie Bones family.

I couldn’t resist returning for happy hour. The atmosphere was lively, and the appetizers were to die for. The calamari, paired with a glass of crisp white wine, was a standout. It became clear why this spot is so beloved for a date night too. The Italian cuisine, rich with flavors, set the perfect stage.

For dinner, the Chicken Marsala paired with an expertly selected wine was unforgettable. Every bite, every sip was a reflection of their passion for great food and hospitality. If you’re seeking a place that combines nostalgia with exceptional service, Frankie Bones is a must-visit.

New York City Pizza

Stepping into New York City Pizza, I felt an immediate rush of nostalgia, as if I’d been transported straight to a cozy pizzeria in the heart of Manhattan. The aroma of authentic flavors filled the air, reminding me of my childhood trips to the Big Apple. What stood out immediately were the generous slice sizes, each one a meal in itself. It’s a place where the passion for pizza is evident in every bite.

As I savored my first slice, I couldn’t help but notice the magical sauce, a well-guarded secret recipe that perfectly balanced sweetness and tanginess. The crust was crispy yet chewy, just as it should be. Their menu also boasts a variety of classic Italian dishes, making it more than just a pizza joint.

Here’s why New York City Pizza should be on your must-visit list:

  1. Authentic flavors that transport you straight to New York.
  2. Large slice sizes ensuring you get your fill.
  3. Secret recipe for the sauce that sets it apart.

Sharing these delightful experiences with others brings joy, and I can confidently say New York City Pizza is a slice of heaven on Hilton Head Island.

Conclusion

After exploring Hilton Head’s pizza scene, I’ve realized it’s not just about the food—it’s the memories attached to each bite. From sharing laughs over a cheesy slice at Giuseppi’s to the first time I tasted the smoky crust at Il Carpaccio, each spot has a story.

So, next time you’re on the island, don’t just eat pizza—experience it. Trust me, every slice has a tale waiting to be told.

Comments are closed.